How to get the perfect finish

[TDS87]

I decided a few years back to make my own cue as I’m a joiner. This has finally been finished now and I put an oil finish on. It did not turn out how I expected, it was very dull and wouldn’t shine up.

I previously owned a Parris cue that I stupidly sold….and my brother in law has just bought a Jason Owen cue. Both of these have the most amazing finish to them but I just can’t seem to replicate it.

Any secret tips, products or processes that would help?

Thanks!