Originally Posted by trevs1
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
How much pressure on Bridge hand?
Collapse
X
-
Thanks j6uk
My thanks are just for having an open mind, I don't mean to preach but I have been a member for a long time and have never posted a negative response to any other user on this site.
If I have a thought about a subject I will give a view, but if my view is to be dismissive or rude the I would rather not respond at all.
I don't mean to be disrespectful of anybody but I did find trevs posts patronising and rude.
While I respect your views trev ..I would have thought you would have used a less offensive manor to write them.
Comment
-
To be fair to Trevor White I have played the game years and never heard of this either so I was sceptical too -
I think players in general alter the grip for certain shots and this technique probably works best on the aforementioned shots close in with less pull back but more power needed and the results for me has been more accuracy with more power rather than using a longer back swing to generate the same power which carries a little less percentage - The other night I found myself doing it naturally during games and I made 3 60's a few 50's and 40's and generally very consistent all evening to the point the other guy who usually wins a few said he was totally destroyed and felt he was here just to take balls out for me.
A little gentle pressure at times was all that was needed - This is where I think people mis-understood the advice - trying possibly to replicate Judd shots lol - For me it helped feeling a little gentle pressure on the bridge - not a bendy coiled spring or wham smack it in Judd - although I will be trying out a few Judd Trump things for a laugh - I just built it up gradually and tried it out on certain shots we have mentioned = maybe it is just something that felt good slotting into my game because of my grip. It may not work for everyone but it is whatever feels natural and I am comfy changing my grip for certain shots so my assessment is that I feel like I have added something to my game.
Therefore while it may not be understood properly or might not feel natural for everyone it has for me and I thank the posters for coming out and saying it -
I will say this too - in closing some people - experienced players - can give some good advice that does not come from a coaching manual - it is maybe wrong to just knock that advice on a thread without trying it out first yourself - Like getting a Trevor White cue in the post and then slating it first without playing a game - now how would that feel?
Comment
-
Just wanted to say that I tried this technique last night but couldn't really manage it!? For me, I just couldn't figure out how to manipulate my grip in order to generate any extra downforce into my bridge. Perhaps I haven't grasped how much extra downforce is being talked about?
Evidently we're not talking about creating cue bend - that is too extreme! But enough to crush a grape, for example?
Comment
-
Originally Posted by Byrom View PostTo be fair to Trevor White I have played the game years and never heard of this either so I was sceptical too -
I think players in general alter the grip for certain shots and this technique probably works best on the aforementioned shots close in with less pull back but more power needed and the results for me has been more accuracy with more power rather than using a longer back swing to generate the same power which carries a little less percentage - The other night I found myself doing it naturally during games and I made 3 60's a few 50's and 40's and generally very consistent all evening to the point the other guy who usually wins a few said he was totally destroyed and felt he was here just to take balls out for me.
A little gentle pressure at times was all that was needed - This is where I think people mis-understood the advice - trying possibly to replicate Judd shots lol - For me it helped feeling a little gentle pressure on the bridge - not a bendy coiled spring or wham smack it in Judd - although I will be trying out a few Judd Trump things for a laugh - I just built it up gradually and tried it out on certain shots we have mentioned = maybe it is just something that felt good slotting into my game because of my grip. It may not work for everyone but it is whatever feels natural and I am comfy changing my grip for certain shots so my assessment is that I feel like I have added something to my game.
Therefore while it may not be understood properly or might not feel natural for everyone it has for me and I thank the posters for coming out and saying it -
I will say this too - in closing some people - experienced players - can give some good advice that does not come from a coaching manual - it is maybe wrong to just knock that advice on a thread without trying it out first yourself - Like getting a Trevor White cue in the post and then slating it first without playing a game - now how would that feel?
yes you are right it works for certain shots..as I said all along, with persistance it can become a real asset.
It is very hard to describe to somebody how much downforce is needed..its not much and that is why people have become confused with cue bending and a tight grip...its none of these is just a very controlled technique and I think it could help a few players develop a stronger game.
Comment
-
Originally Posted by timcunnell View PostJust wanted to say that I tried this technique last night but couldn't really manage it!? For me, I just couldn't figure out how to manipulate my grip in order to generate any extra downforce into my bridge. Perhaps I haven't grasped how much extra downforce is being talked about?
Evidently we're not talking about creating cue bend - that is too extreme! But enough to crush a grape, for example?
Sorry this was of no use to you, but thanks for the reply.Last edited by buddfridgeman; 10 April 2015, 10:41 AM.
Comment
-
Ah thanks Budd. No I will definitely try again with this. Like you said before, those who've tried this (and good players too!) have reported back that it helps. So I am not writing it off just yet. Back on the practice table this weekend and I will have another go.
(I was playing a friendly match with a mate last night so didn't really get the chance to try it out too much! I need a line-up or something for stuff like this!).
Thanks again for your advice
Comment
-
I tend to find it works best when in close stunning, screwing or following through, my advice would be start off with blacks off the spot using swallow angles...get a feel for it from there and expand a little.
I wouldnt consider this a cue action for every shot but close in and forcing angles or screws work a treat for me.
Comment
-
Originally Posted by Byrom View PostA little gentle pressure at times was all that was needed - This is where I think people mis-understood the advice - trying possibly to replicate Judd shots lol - For me it helped feeling a little gentle pressure on the bridge - not a bendy coiled spring or wham smack it in Judd - although I will be trying out a few Judd Trump things for a laugh - I just built it up gradually and tried it out on certain shots we have mentioned = maybe it is just something that felt good slotting into my game because of my grip. It may not work for everyone but it is whatever feels natural and I am comfy changing my grip for certain shots so my assessment is that I feel like I have added something to my game.
Comment
-
I thought the original post was about applying pressure on the cue (but not bending it like Trump) between the bridge and the grip by only using the grip and bridge with the chin and chest not involved. It would require a lot of pressure on the web between forefinger and thumb and my thoughts are that cannot be a good thing. Also the back of the grip would have to be raised in order to push the cue downwards.
Very easy to do using the bridge, chin, chest and grip by just lifting the butt and lowering the chin and chest.Terry Davidson
IBSF Master Coach & Examiner
Comment
-
Originally Posted by Terry Davidson View PostI thought the original post was about applying pressure on the cue (but not bending it like Trump) between the bridge and the grip by only using the grip and bridge with the chin and chest not involved. It would require a lot of pressure on the web between forefinger and thumb and my thoughts are that cannot be a good thing. Also the back of the grip would have to be raised in order to push the cue downwards.
Very easy to do using the bridge, chin, chest and grip by just lifting the butt and lowering the chin and chest.
Clearly, it's the lifting of the grip all along that causes bending of the shaft in a Trump stylie. Deliberate downward pressure onto the bridge, by placing pressure through the grip hand is never a good idea. Any book, coach or player who knows anything about technique will state the grip should be fairly loose, which is (or would be) impossible if the grip was having to provide pressure though the cue and onto the shaft. I'm sure virtually everyone worth their salt would agree with that too. The idea that a pressurised cue shaft at address stores some kind of energy is just ludicrous and should not be taken seriously. If someone feels that's a winner for them, then great, knock yourself out trying that and good luck. But, to suggest it's something that can help other players is a recipe for trouble.
Edit to add....
What exactly is the reference to "coiled spring" about in post 16, 20, 22, 43 and so on.?.... Also, I have never heard the term "downforce" used in relation to good cueing.
I know this is stating the obvious here but to me......
Great cueing is where a player delivers a cue consistently, along a straight line, in as flat a plane as is reasonably possible and with the desired amount of acceleration. Put it this way...If you could use a magic eraser and make the player disappear, so all you could see is the cue travelling through the shot, you would see it moving straight, flat (or flat...ish) and without bending at all before contact. Spin and power are generated by the speed of delivery, coupled with correct point of contact on the cueball and a tip travelling right through and beyond the point of contact against the cueball. Yes, some players have a greater ability to create more power, just as some cues will enable the creation of more movement on the white easily, but the principles are the same for all.
Advocating a technique which attempts to emulate a player (Judd) who causes some bend to his cue shaft during backswing is not great advice, no matter how you slice it. Stating in post 44 that "we have established that Judd Trump uses his chin to bend the cue" is simply not true at all. It's what "you" have assumed to be true, not "we". He bends the cue because he raises his grip hand during backswing, while not raising or moving his head, nothing more than that. He gets his accuracy and power from delivering the cue piston straight with fabulous timing, right through the cueball. The fact that he might have a very responsive cue perhaps helps too, I don't know as I've not used his cue, but on those cloths, moving the white is not too tricky. Joe Swail had shedloads of cuepower, but would anyone want to copy that technique.?...I'd guess not. If anyone wants to model themselves on anything, it should be technical correctness as much as possible. Look to O'Sullivan, Murphy and suchlike if you want to learn how to go about achieving a fabulous technique.
I understand that you weren't the original poster and that your comments are coming with good intentions, but I would be utterly amazed if any professional player actually deliberately applies the sort of pressure required to the cue, in order to bend the shaft intentionally through the shot. Please, if anyone knows of one, let me know and I'll happily eat my words. I apologise for being fairly harsh and critical in my comments, but I stand by the essence of what I wrote. The whole idea of any excessive downward pressure on the cue is simply wrong, whereas doing so to cause deliberate bending of the cue shaft is madness. It is not good advice at all.
I do not post anything just to be argumentative and try to be open to others views, especially when they have merit and come from sound foundations with no agenda.
Anyway, that really is it from me.
Note.... @ J6uk
I'm not really sure what you're getting at in post 61, but I have a suggestion.
Why doesn't someone email the BBC and ask a question on this when the WC is on.?
A question such as....
"Why does Judd's cue bend during his backswing, and is this something he (or others) would do deliberately to create more control / power.? Is there a benefit to this.?
I'll give £100 to charity of the Forums (or Ferret's) choice if someone gets that question answered on air for all to hear the reply.Last edited by trevs1; 11 April 2015, 05:37 PM.
Comment
Comment