Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

No marker

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • No marker

    They're just showing Dott v. Dale in the interval, and I notice that, apart from not televising one of the tables, it seems thay can't afford a marker to be employed on both tables!

    Dott-Dale was on the untelevised table (I assume it was actually recorded simply because the O'Sullivan-Day match was over so quickly), and you can clearly see Alan Chamberlain's doofer which he uses to alter the scoreboard.

    Which, as well as giving the referee an extra thing to concentrate on, means that the matches are not recorded. (I use 'recorded' in the technical sense that means that the marker has a sheet on which every single stroke is recorded on the match sheet.)

    This does actually have some significance quite apart from the fact that the WSA must be on an economy drive. If the referee mis-calls the score, or mis-alters the scoreboard, and a few shots later the error comes to light, there is no way of reconciling the error and confirm which is right.

    Seems very unusual for the latter stages of a ranking tournament.

  • #2
    I don't have Eurosport, and can't see what's going on..but that sounds like a pretty poor show!
    Science is a refinement of everyday thinking -- Albert Einstein

    Comment


    • #3
      That's well spotted Statman... The extrer refs only stayed til last sixteen so it luks like theyve kept the four top refs to do all the work now...

      Comment


      • #4
        It is entirely the norm in qualifying rounds, but that is the same for all players at that stage of the tournament.

        However, why should Ken Doherty and Ding Junhui be afforded a referee and marker for their quarter-final but not Stephen Lee and Shaun Murphy for theirs?

        It is, on the face of it, a triviality, but treatment of all players who reach a certain stage of the tournament should surely be equal?

        Interesting point about only the four referees left. But even that would be a valid excuse only until Thursady, because today (Friday) there were only two tables in operation. Four officials between two tables would appear, on the mathematical face of it, to divide equally into a ref and a marker on each table!

        Comment


        • #5
          surely if they dont have a marker for the scores they can just use a pencil.

          ?

          Comment

          Working...
          X