Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

PTC 10 Sheffield

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally Posted by rhys1337 View Post
    peter did NOT look happy with that, at all
    hahaha.
    No, he seemed to be complaining about the table or something, often likes a bit of a post match
    chat does Peter.

    -
    The fast and the furious,
    The slow and labourious,
    All of us, glorious parts of the whole!

    Comment


    • #32
      That was a tough game. There seemed to be a determination in White to win that after that free ball incident and going 2-1 down. Ebdon not happy at the end, moaning about the table. Said it was garbage and it's usually worse than that. It did have a lot of bounce though.

      Comment


      • #33
        Definitly could see a more determined jimmy after the incident, and fair play to him, he dug deep and got a good victory.
        Blown away

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally Posted by jw147 View Post
          Definitly could see a more determined jimmy after the incident, and fair play to him, he dug deep and got a good victory.
          Yes, you know I think it was just what he needed to get a bit of a spark going.

          -
          The fast and the furious,
          The slow and labourious,
          All of us, glorious parts of the whole!

          Comment


          • #35
            Originally Posted by PatBlock View Post
            Yes, you know I think it was just what he needed to get a bit of a spark going.

            -
            True, it got his juices flowing lol

            And yes, peter does always like a bit of an after match chat. Theres a lot of respect between him and jim, they both must of tapped the table a hundred times!
            Blown away

            Comment


            • #36
              Anyone know what match is being shown after this dott match?
              Blown away

              Comment


              • #37
                Originally Posted by jw147 View Post
                Anyone know what match is being shown after this dott match?
                I think Williams- Yu Delu
                "There has only ever been Alex Higgins, myself and now Ronnie O'sullivan who play the game the way it should be played with such excitement - I know the fans love it this way" - Jimmy White

                Comment


                • #38
                  Great result for Anthony McGill, a 4-0 victory over Jimmy White.

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    any working video?
                    Photos from the masters 2011
                    http://irishphoto.photoshelter.com/

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally Posted by irishsnooker View Post
                      any working video?
                      Have you tried the links at the top of this thread? They're working ok here.

                      -
                      Last edited by PatBlock; 29 November 2011, 10:44 PM.
                      The fast and the furious,
                      The slow and labourious,
                      All of us, glorious parts of the whole!

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Originally Posted by irishsnooker View Post
                        any working video?
                        Choice of both tables here, Fergal O'Brien is on table 2
                        http://www.sportlemon.tv/

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Wow that Dave Harold is a slow player, but got the win in the end

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Originally Posted by nrage View Post
                            I missed the details of the discussion on the Jimmy/Ebdon table .. what was the fuss all about, whether it was a free ball or not? Whether the yellow could be struck at both extreme edges? And the answer was yes it could, no free ball?
                            Michaela called a free ball which would have given Jimmy an easy blue ... Peter queried it so Michaela put a test ball next to the yellow (the ball on) and confirmed her decision, a free ball ... Peter continued to whinge so Michaela offered to get a senior referee and got Jan Verhaas ... Jan spent a couple of minutes looking at it and eventually concluded "no, not a free ball" and play went on on that basis ...

                            Poor refereeing in my opinion ... I can understand why Michaela offered to get a senior ref's opinion (her words, not mine) although I'd have preferred her to stand her ground ... and I'm even less impressed with Jan Verhaas who came in and decided it as if he was refereeing the match - which he wasn't ... I think he should have unequivocally backed up Michaela's decision ...

                            It was a judgement call ... Peter thought it wasn't, Michaela thought it was and called "free ball" and, quite properly, reviewed her decision and confirmed "free ball", Jan thought it wasn't and for the record I thought it was (my best guess from the standard camera angle) ...

                            I thought the referee's decision was final but apparently not ... whatever next, maybe they should do phone votes a la Strictly or the X-Factor? Phone xxx-xxxx if you think it's a free ball or yyy-yyyy if you don't ...

                            I am very disappointed - my view is that Jan Verhaas should have simply stated that Michaela is the match referee and her decision is final whether it is right or wrong ...

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Correct Dandy. I don't blame Ver Haas really. I blame Tabb. She should never have put herself in that position. At least the decision didn't affect the result of the match. Shame Jimmy lost his 2nd game but Mcgill obviously played well, so good luck to him.

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Originally Posted by DandyA View Post
                                Michaela called a free ball which would have given Jimmy an easy blue ... Peter queried it so Michaela put a test ball next to the yellow (the ball on) and confirmed her decision, a free ball ... Peter continued to whinge so Michaela offered to get a senior referee and got Jan Verhaas ... Jan spent a couple of minutes looking at it and eventually concluded "no, not a free ball" and play went on on that basis ...

                                Poor refereeing in my opinion ... I can understand why Michaela offered to get a senior ref's opinion (her words, not mine) although I'd have preferred her to stand her ground ... and I'm even less impressed with Jan Verhaas who came in and decided it as if he was refereeing the match - which he wasn't ... I think he should have unequivocally backed up Michaela's decision ...

                                It was a judgement call ... Peter thought it wasn't, Michaela thought it was and called "free ball" and, quite properly, reviewed her decision and confirmed "free ball", Jan thought it wasn't and for the record I thought it was (my best guess from the standard camera angle) ...

                                I thought the referee's decision was final but apparently not ... whatever next, maybe they should do phone votes a la Strictly or the X-Factor? Phone xxx-xxxx if you think it's a free ball or yyy-yyyy if you don't ...

                                I am very disappointed - my view is that Jan Verhaas should have simply stated that Michaela is the match referee and her decision is final whether it is right or wrong ...
                                Very odd situation, and seems quite untypical of Michaela who can be quite forceful when she wants to. Seems quite untypical of Ebdon too. If I was Michaela, also I'd have been a bit annoyed that Jan Ver Haas didn't back her up, but I didn't see it.

                                It might have been quite clearly not a free ball. Without seeing it, it's hard to say who was in the wrong in this instance.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X