If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Suppose you had a bag with 600 red snooker balls and would at each turn randomly take 15 of them and mark them. At the best case scenario (choosing only unmarked balls) one could mark all balls after 40 turns, but how many balls would be actually marked after those 40 turns and how many turns would one need to mark 90% of the balls.
Excel solutions worth 1/2 point, others 1 point. (by PM)
Deadline Tuesday-12:00 pm (GMT)
I'll PM you my questions on this, because I don't think I can have understood it correctly... if I have, it it is far too easy
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
I have another try at rewording:
Suppose you had a bag with 600 red snooker balls and would at each turn randomly take 15 of them, mark them and here is the important part, return them to the bag. At the best case scenario (choosing only unmarked balls) it is clear that one could mark all balls after 40 turns. But picking the balls randomly (or blind) how many balls would be probably marked after 40 turns and how many turns would one need to mark 90% of the balls.
Excel solutions worth 1/2 point, others 1 point. (by PM)
Deadline Tuesday-12:00 pm (GMT)
red pink into pink pocket red green ... green ....... red black .... black ....... red blue ...... yellow ..... red pink ...... pink ........ red green ... green ....... red black .... black ....... red blue ..... yellow ...... red pink ..... pink ......... red green ... green ....... red black .... black ....... red blue ..... yellow ....... red pink ...... pink ......... red green ....green ........ red black .... black ....... yellow .. yellow ...... green ... brown ....... brown ... green ....... blue ...... blue ........ pink ...... green ....... black ..... black .......
red
black into black pocket
red
pink ....... green ........
red
blue ....... blue ..........
red
black ..... yellow ........
red
pink ....... pink ...........
red
blue ....... green .........
red
black ...... black .........
red
pink ........ green ........
red
blue ........ blue ..........
red
black ...... yellow ........
red
pink ........ pink ...........
red
blue ........ green ........
red
black ...... black .........
red
pink ........ green ........
red
blue ........ blue ..........
yellow ..... yellow .......
green ...... brown .......
brown ..... green ........
blue ........ blue ..........
pink ........ green ........
black ....... black ........
I have another try at rewording:
Suppose you had a bag with 600 red snooker balls and would at each turn randomly take 15 of them, mark them and here is the important part, return them to the bag. At the best case scenario (choosing only unmarked balls) it is clear that one could mark all balls after 40 turns. But picking the balls randomly (or blind) how many balls would be probably marked after 40 turns and how many turns would one need to mark 90% of the balls.
Excel solutions worth 1/2 point, others 1 point. (by PM)
Deadline Tuesday-12:00 pm (GMT)
This, of course, is round 66.
Um I'm still not sure what is being asked
1) What is meant by "probably marked after 40 turns"? Do you mean what is the average (i.e. "expected") number of balls that would be marked after 40 turns?
2) To mark 90% of the balls, you would need at least 90% x 40 turns = 36 turns! But I'm not going to let anyone get a point for that
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
Here is round 67, to run at the same time as snookersfun's round 66!
Gordon is teaching me some advanced maths. "Write out the numbers 1 to 10," he tells me. "How many digits do you need to write?"
I decide to count the digits out on my own digits - I start using my fingers, and find that I haven't got enough, so use one of my toes.
"11," I reply (realising that the 11 digits I need are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 1, 0).
"Well done, davis_greatest!" says Gordon.
"And how many digits do you need to write out the numbers 1 to 1,000,000,000?" he asks me.
I start counting out on my fingers, toes, and anything else I can find, but soon run out. I am stumped. What should I tell Gordon?
Answers by PM please, so Gordon doesn't know I have asked for help. Initial Deadline is 21:00 GMT on Wednesday 29 November.
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
In response to a question I have received, I have asked Gordon to clarify. He wants to know the number of digits I would need to write - not the number of different digits.
For instance, if he wanted me to write the numbers from 1 to 15, I would need 21 digits:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1 0
1 1
1 2
1 3
1 4
1 5
Count them - there are 21 digits here. I had to use more than my fingers and toes to count that high.
But Gordon doesn't want me just to write the numbers from 1 to 15... he wants me to write the numbers 1 to 1000000000
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
I will shortly post snookersfun's round 66, slightly reworded!
elvaago and snookersfun, so far, have sent me correct answers to round 67 (although there is a neater method than that found by either of them!). Round 67 is still open for anyone else to have a go.
HERE IS THE SCOREBOARD AFTER ROUND 65 BUT BEFORE ROUND 66 AND WITH POINTS INCLUDED SO FAR FOR ROUND 67 FOR ELVAAGO AND SNOOKERSFUN
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
Well surely it's 9+(2×90)+(3×900)+(4×9000)+...+(9×900000000)+1 which is 8,888,888,890
Very close - but not close enough for Gordon
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
That is the correct answer! One very slightly different way to think of it would be to start by considering the numbers 0 to 999,999,999 (1,000,000,000 numbers).
If these all had 9 digits, there would be 9 x 1,000,000,000 digits = 9,000,000,000
But:
- the first 100,000,000 numbers don't have a digit in the 9th column from the right (the "hundred millions"), so subtract 100,000,000
- the first 10,000,000 numbers don't have a digit in the 8th column from the right (the "ten millions"), so subtract 10,000,000
- the first 1,000,000 numbers don't have a digit in the 7th column from the right, so subtract 1,000,000
... etc until we get to
- the first 10 numbers don't have a digit in the 2nd column from the right (the "tens"), so subtract 10
- the first 1 number (0) doesn't have a digit in the 1st column from the right (the "units") as it isn't on the list at all, so subtract 1.
We are left with
9,000,000,000 - 111,111,111 = 8,888,888,889.
Now add 10 digits for the number 1,000,000,000 and get 8,888,888,899
I need to decide whether still to award 1 point to anyone who submits the correct answer by PM by the Initial Deadline
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
Points for round 67 also awarded to The Statman and to chasmmi:
HERE IS THE SCOREBOARD AFTER ROUND 65 BUT BEFORE ROUND 66 AND WITH POINTS INCLUDED SO FAR FOR ROUND 67 FOR ELVAAGO, SNOOKERSFUN, THE STATMAN AND CHASMMI
"If anybody can knock these three balls in, this man can." David Taylor, 11 January 1982, as Steve Davis prepared to pot the blue, in making the first 147 break on television.
Comment